Enter your email below to receive weekly updates from the Ashton College blog straight to your inbox.
As students head back to school, many find themselves grappling with a pivotal question: Is post-secondary education still the most effective path to a meaningful and well-paying career? Historically, obtaining a college or university degree has been viewed as a surefire way to secure financial stability and long-term professional success. However, with the rapid evolution of the digital economy and the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), the value of traditional education is increasingly being called into question.
In a recent interview with the CBC, personal finance expert Mark Ting offered his insights on this issue, shedding light on the factors prospective students should consider before pursuing post-secondary education. Let’s explore some of his key points and analyze what they mean in today’s job market.
According to Ting, education should be viewed as an investment—an investment in yourself. “Most people say you’re investing in yourself, so you have to do your due diligence,” he told CBC. Ting emphasized that a degree often comes with a significant commitment of time, money, and effort, which is why it’s crucial to weigh the potential returns on this investment.
For decades, earning a degree was seen as one of the most reliable ways to guarantee long-term career prospects. However, in today’s shifting economy, degrees no longer hold the same security. The value of higher education depends largely on the field of study and whether the skills learned are in demand. For example, degrees in STEM fields (science, technology, engineering, and math) often offer strong job prospects, while degrees in the arts or humanities may require more careful planning.
Ting highlights that students need to critically evaluate their post-graduation plans. He frequently asks his students, “What does day one after graduation look like?” If a student can clearly map out their future job prospects and knows how to market the skills they’ve acquired, the degree is likely to pay off. However, for those who cannot answer this question, it may be wise to rethink or delay their educational pursuits.
In today’s financial climate, student loans are often the only option for many to afford post-secondary education. Ting pointed out that while student loans can be “good debt” if they lead to a high-paying job, they can also become a burden if graduates struggle to find well-paying work.
During the CBC interview, Ting explained, “With any investment or lending, it heightens the rewards but also the penalties.” If graduates are able to quickly pay off their loans, the debt is manageable. But, for many, the lack of immediate employment or underemployment can result in financial hardship. The opportunity cost of student loans—both in terms of time and money—must be weighed carefully.
Ting’s advice is to assess the potential long-term benefits before taking out loans. If a student isn’t confident that their degree will translate into a high-paying job within a reasonable period, accumulating debt may not be the best course of action. His perspective resonates with growing concerns about the student debt crisis, where more people are questioning the financial viability of borrowing money to finance higher education.
One of the more personal insights Ting shared during his CBC interview was about his son’s decision to take a gap year instead of immediately enrolling in university. Ting encouraged his son to spend time working and traveling, giving him the space to figure out his long-term career goals before committing to post-secondary education.
“He didn’t have a focused career path,” Ting said. “I actually encouraged him not to go to school.” Instead, his son worked for a few months, saved money, and travelled to Japan, gaining valuable life experience. Ting noted that while his son made some mistakes, the real-world lessons learned during this time were invaluable.
Taking a gap year is becoming an increasingly popular option for students who want to gain practical experience before committing to an expensive education. Research suggests that students who take a gap year often return to school more focused and with clearer goals. This strategy can help students avoid the pitfalls of pursuing a degree in a field they aren’t passionate about or that lacks job opportunities.
One of the most thought-provoking points Ting made in the CBC interview was about the rise of artificial intelligence and how it may disrupt the traditional job market. Ting warned that AI has the potential to replace many white-collar jobs, particularly those that involve routine, knowledge-based tasks.
“Artificial intelligence is fairly new, so it’s only going to get better from here,” Ting explained. He pointed out that many students entering the workforce today may find themselves competing with AI for jobs that once required a university degree. However, Ting also emphasized the importance of learning to use AI as a tool, rather than seeing it as a threat. He advises his students to use AI to enhance their problem-solving and critical-thinking skills. “If you just copy and paste answers from AI, you’re the exact type of person that artificial intelligence is going to replace,” he warned. Instead, students should focus on synthesizing information and adding value that AI cannot replicate.
The lesson here is clear: in an era of rapid technological change, adaptability is key. Students who embrace new technologies and learn how to leverage them to their advantage are more likely to succeed in the evolving job market.
So, is post-secondary education still the best path to a meaningful career? According to Mark Ting, the answer depends on your goals, planning, and ability to adapt to a changing world. If you have a clear career path and marketable skills, a degree can be a valuable investment. However, if you're uncertain about your future, it may be worth considering alternatives like a gap year, gaining work experience, or exploring new technologies like AI.
Ultimately, the key takeaway from Ting’s CBC interview is that education should be a strategic decision, not an automatic one. Whether pursuing a degree or exploring other options, students should carefully evaluate their choices and make informed decisions that align with their long-term goals.
The information contained in this post is considered true and accurate as of the publication date. However, the accuracy of this information may be impacted by changes in circumstances that occur after the time of publication. Ashton College assumes no liability for any error or omissions in the information contained in this post or any other post in our blog.
